When whisky enthusiasts debate single malt versus blended whisky, they explore two distinct styles with unique characteristics. Made only from malted barley at a single distillery, single malt whisky has a distinctive flavour and is highly individualistic.
In contrast, blended whisky combines malt and grain whiskies from various distilleries, creating a smoother, more consistent profile.
Comparing these two types helps whisky lovers understand their diverse flavour profiles and make more informed choices based on their personal taste preferences.
What Is Single Malt Whisky?
Single-malt Scotch whisky, originating from Scotland, is celebrated for its complex and varied flavour profiles. It pairs excellently with strong cheeses and dark chocolate or can be enjoyed neat. Each bottle reflects the unique characteristics of its distillery and maturation process, offering a distinctive tasting experience that Scotch whisky enthusiasts cherish.
Our taste test of the Ardbeg Ardcore Single Malt Scotch Whisky from The Whisky Master, a whisky shop in London, revealed an exciting and intense flavour profile highlighting roasted black malt, a distinctive element in this limited-edition release.
The nose opens with rich notes of dark chocolate, brittle toffee, and aniseed, layered with a hint of charcoal. On the palate, the whisky delivers a bold combination of roasted malt, citrus, and a touch of mint, balanced by vanilla sweetness.
Despite being an Islay whisky, it showcases less peat than typical Ardbeg expressions, focusing more on the unique roasted malt character.
What Does It Taste Like?
Nose: Dark chocolate, brittle toffee, aniseed, and a hint of charcoal.
Palate: Roasted malt, citrus, mint, and vanilla.
Colour: Light gold, influenced by its time in ex-bourbon barrels.
Finish: Long and bold, with lingering notes of roasted malt and subtle smokiness.
Alcohol Content: Typically ranges between 40% and 60% ABV. The higher end of this range often signifies a cask strength or higher proof version, intensifying the whisky's flavour profile.
Rating: 🥃🥃🥃🥃🥃
What Is Blended Whisky?
Blended Scotch whisky combines single-grain Scotch whisky and single-malt Scotch whisky from different distilleries, resulting in a balanced and versatile flavour profile. It pairs well with various foods, from light snacks to hearty meals, and is suitable for casual and formal occasions. Its consistency and approachability make it a popular choice among whisky drinkers.
Our tasting of the Hibiki 12-Year-Old 70cl truly showcased the craftsmanship and elegance of Japanese whisky. From the first sniff, this whisky has a fantastic sense of sweet and rich aromas of ripe oranges, honey and a subtle floral undertone with hints of cinnamon and plum. These vibrant notes, influenced by the whisky's ageing in a combination of sherry, bourbon, and Mizunara oak casks, create a delightful bouquet that sets high expectations.
On the palate, Hibiki 12 continues to impress with its smooth and velvety texture. You’ll find a harmony of crushed almonds, caramelised fruits, and a touch of clove-spiced oranges. There is a gentle oakiness that provides depth without overpowering the sweetness. The influence of Mizunara oak adds a subtle spiciness that complements the fruity core of this whisky, making each sip a layered and satisfying experience.
What Does It Taste Like?
Nose: Honey, ripe oranges, cinnamon, subtle plum, and a delicate floral touch.
Palate: Smooth and rich with caramelised fruit, almonds, and a hint of spiced oak.
Colour: Golden amber, reflecting its time in Mizunara and other oak casks.
Finish: Long and balanced, with citrus peel, mild spices, and a soft oak presence.
Alcohol Content: Generally between 40% and 43% ABV. This moderate alcohol content contributes to its smooth, versatile nature.
Rating: 🥃🥃🥃
Rating Scale:
🥃: Poor – Lacks character, unbalanced, not enjoyable.
🥃🥃: Fair – Some redeeming qualities but generally underwhelming.
🥃🥃🥃: Good – Solid performance, balanced, enjoyable for most.
🥃🥃🥃🥃: Very Good – High quality, complex, and satisfying.
🥃🥃🥃🥃🥃: Excellent – Outstanding, exceptional complexity, and highly recommended.
Quick Comparison Table
|
How Are They Different?
Age Statements
Single malt whiskies frequently have age statements indicating how long the blends have been aged in casks. Due to longer maturation, older single malts often develop deeper, richer flavours. For instance, a highly prized 12-year-old single malt whisky might exhibit more developed characteristics than a younger one. The age statement helps consumers gauge the whisky’s potential quality and depth.
In contrast, blended Scotch whisky usually does not have specific age statements. This is because it is a mix of various whiskies from different casks and distilleries. The emphasis here is on creating a balanced, consistent flavour profile rather than highlighting the age of individual components.
Production Process
Single malts are made from malted barley and produced at a single distillery using traditional pot stills. This process allows each distillery to impart unique characteristics to the new-release whisky bottles, resulting in distinctive flavour profiles tied to specific locations and methods.
Single malts, like the Glenmorangie Ealanta, use different cask types, such as sherry or bourbon oak barrels, to impart various flavour notes, from fruity to spicy. The single distillery approach means that all aspects of production, from fermentation to maturation, are controlled, leading to a malt whisky with a unique identity.
On the other hand, blended Scotch whisky combines malt and grain whiskies from multiple distilleries. The production goal is to create a smooth and consistent flavour profile that appeals to a broader audience.
By blending different whiskies, producers can balance various flavour notes and achieve a harmonious taste. This process allows for greater flexibility and consistency, as the final product can be adjusted to maintain a desired flavour profile, regardless of variations in individual components.
Taste Profile
Single malt Scotch whiskies offer a diverse and rich taste experience due to the specific methods and casks used in their production. Each single malt Scotch whisky has its own unique profile, influenced by the distillery’s location, cask finishing types, and ageing conditions.
The flavours of this distilled spirit can range from sweet and fruity to smoky and peaty, reflecting the whisky’s origin and maturation process. This complexity makes the single malt Scotch whisky a favourite among enthusiasts who appreciate nuanced and distinctive flavours.
The blended Scotch whisky, however, provides a more uniform and approachable taste. The blending process aims to smooth out the individual characteristics of the malt and grain whiskies, resulting in a balanced flavour consistent from bottle to bottle. This makes the distilled spirit versatile and suitable for various drinking occasions, whether enjoyed neat, on the rocks, or in cocktails.
Price
Single malt whiskies are typically more expensive due to the costs associated with their production and ageing. The lengthy maturation process and by using high-quality casks add to the overall expense. Additionally, single malt whiskies often have smaller production runs than blends, further increasing their price. This higher cost reflects the craftsmanship and time invested in creating a complex and refined whisky.
The blended whisky is generally more affordable than most rare and collectable whisky bottels, thanks to economies of scale and the blending process, which can include a mix of more economical grain whiskies. The ability to source and blend various whiskies helps keep costs down, making the Scotch distilled blends a more budget-friendly option. This accessibility allows consumers to enjoy quality whisky at a lower price point.
Tip: You can easily score whisky offers and deals from online whisky shops.
Alcohol Content
Individual Scotch single malts often have a higher ABV (alcohol by volume), ranging from 40% to 60%. This higher strength can enhance the whisky’s robust flavours and provide a more intense tasting experience.
The Scotch blended whisky usually has a lower ABV, typically between 40% and 43%. This lower strength contributes to a smoother and more approachable profile, making blended whiskies easier to enjoy in various settings.
Serving Suggestions
Scotch single malts are often enjoyed neat or with a small splash of water. This method allows drinkers to fully experience the whisky’s complex flavours and aromas without dilution. The subtle changes from adding a few drops of water can open up new flavour notes, enhancing the overall tasting experience.
Blended Scotches like Chivas Regal are more versatile in how they can be enjoyed. They can be sipped neat, on the rocks, or used in cocktails. This flexibility makes blended Scotches suitable for a range of occasions and preferences, whether you're looking for a straightforward sip or a base for mixed drinks. Their balanced profile and smoothness make them popular for casual and sophisticated settings.
FAQs
Is single malt better than blended whisky for health?
Both single malt and blended whisky contain similar levels of alcohol and should be consumed in moderation. Neither offers significant health benefits over the other. Just drink responsibly and in moderation to minimise potential health risks.
Which is higher in sugar, single malt or blended whisky?
Generally, neither single malt nor blended whisky contains high sugar levels. The sweetness of Scotch whisky comes from the cask maturation and the spirit's inherent characteristics. Blended whiskies may sometimes have slightly higher sugar levels due to added caramel colouring, but this is minimal.
So, Which Is Better?
When choosing between single malt and blended whisky, the decision often comes down to personal preference. Single malt is celebrated for its depth, complexity, and unique characteristics imparted by its specific distillery and maturation process. Most Scotch single malts are often the preferred choice for those who appreciate rich, intricate flavours and a more intense drinking experience.
Blended whisky, however, offers a smoother, more consistent flavour that appeals to a broad audience. Their affordability and versatility make them a popular choice for everyday enjoyment and mixing in cocktails.
In this comparison, single malt Scotch whisky emerges as the winner for its exceptional complexity and distinctiveness. For those looking to explore a diverse range of Scotch whisky options, The Whisky Masters, an online whisky shop, offers an impressive selection of single malt and blended Scotch whiskies. Check them out.